The posts are done, the arguments have been closed, the Rumsfeld Battle is OVAH!
And now, for the Judging. On the panel for this battle...
On the Left:
Jim D of Burnt Orange Report
and Steve S of Scrubland
On the Right:
Urthshu of Urthshu
and Jheka of Daily Blitz
(Anyone may post in this thread - combatants may reply to Judges but may not engage each other. Spoofing a Judge will get you banned but quick.)
Due to haloscan's 1000 character limit and the verbosity of our panel, our Judges are posting their critiques on their web pages listed above by their names.